<P> The Phantom has Christine wear a wedding dress and proposes marriage . Christine admits she does not fear the Phantom for his appearance, but his rage and willingness to kill . Raoul arrives, the Phantom threatening to kill him unless Christine weds him . Christine, pitying the Phantom, kisses him . Moved by her kindness, the Phantom allows the lovers to flee . Before leaving, Christine gives the Phantom her ring in remembrance . The Phantom finds comfort in the papier - mâché monkey, but vanishes as the mob appear, Meg finding his discarded mask . </P> <P> In 1919, the elderly Raoul visits Christine's gravestone, placing the monkey before it . Before leaving, he notices a freshly laid rose with Christine's ring attached to it, implying the Phantom is alive . </P> <Ul> <Li> Gerard Butler as The Phantom </Li> <Li> Emmy Rossum as Christine Daaé </Li> <Li> Patrick Wilson as Viscount Raoul de Chagny </Li> <Li> Miranda Richardson as Madame Giry </Li> <Li> Minnie Driver as Carlotta Giudicelli <Ul> <Li> Margaret Preece as Carlotta's singing voice except for "Learn to Be Lonely" </Li> </Ul> </Li> <Li> Simon Callow as Gilles André </Li> <Li> Ciarán Hinds as Richard Firmin </Li> <Li> Victor McGuire as Ubaldo Piangi </Li> <Li> Jennifer Ellison as Meg Giry </Li> <Li> Murray Melvin as Monsieur Reyer </Li> <Li> Kevin McNally as Joseph Buquet </Li> <Li> James Fleet as Monsieur Lefèvre </Li> <Li> Ramin Karimloo as Gustave Daaé </Li> </Ul> <Li> Gerard Butler as The Phantom </Li>

Gerard butler sing in phantom of the opera