<P> Shirley Rosemary Stelfox (11 April 1941--7 December 2015) was an English television actress, best known for her portrayal of the character Edna Birch, moralising busybody in a Yorkshire village in the popular British soap opera Emmerdale, and as Rose Walton, sister of the snobby and overbearing Hyacinth Bucket in the first series of the comedy series Keeping Up Appearances . The success of the soap had made her a household name in Britain . Furthermore, Stelfox had appeared in many British television soap operas over a fifty - year period . </P> <P> Stelfox was born at Dukinfield, Cheshire on 11 April 1941 . She suffered from bilateral amblyopia, which left her short - sighted . She studied at RADA where her classmates included Edward Fox, John Thaw and Sarah Miles. She was playing in pantomimes at the Old Chapel, Dukinfield, and in productions during the years of her study the town's Lakes Road secondary school . </P> <P> After the Royal Academy of Dramatic Art Stelfox started straight at the BBC in a play called The Case Before You in which she played a 15 year old arsonist - where the prompter did not respond to her long pauses . In December 1960, she appeared in her first episode of Coronation Street . She would later play many different characters in the world - famous soap opera, including, in 1983, running a dating agency in which one of her customers was the entrance cue for Jack Duckworth . She was the first actress to play Hyacinth Bucket's randy sister Rose in the first series of Keeping Up Appearances, but was later replaced by Mary Millar . She appeared in several other well - known television series, including the successful Wicked Women, Making Out with Margi Clarke, Mrs Parkin in Heartbeat, - and Jean in Common as Muck, Juliet Bravo, Coronation Street, The Bill and Crossroads, and Inspector Morse, She played Jane Healy, Melanie Owen's mother, in an episode of EastEnders . She appeared in the short - lived series Albion Market . Stelfox had a long life in different soap operas, briefly appearing in Crossroads (as a police officer), Owen MD and Family Affairs . She had played in Brookside as Madge Richmond (1986 - 87), where she depicted two - timed the widowed pensioner Ralph Hardwick (Ray Dunbobbin), and in 1999 she appeared in two episodes of EastEnders as Jane Healy . Among many others of one - off parts, she played as Alice Hobson in Hobson's Choice (1967), Helen in Civvies (1992), Julie Clegg in Three Seven Eleven (1993 - 94), Jean in Common as Muck (1994) and Mrs Nolan in Lucy Sullivan Is Getting Married (1999 - 2000). </P> <P> She made her debut on screen in David Lean's 1954 romantic comedy Hobson's Choicean where she played together with Sir John Mills and Charles Laughton . Stelfox played the mother of Julie Walters and Victoria Wood in the TV film Pat and Margaret (1994). But her best - known film role came as the "$2.00 Prostitute" in Nineteen Eighty - Four, a film adaptation of the George Orwell novel, starring John Hurt and Richard Burton . Somewhat typecast as a prostitute she played another in Terry Jones's comedy Personal Services (1987) based on the life of Madame Cyn, the brothel owner who entertained celebrities and politicians . </P>

Who has played rose in keeping up appearances
find me the text answering this question