<P> Since the 1964 transfer of Phil Chisnall from United to Liverpool, no player has been transferred directly between the two clubs . Some players, however, have played for both clubs, but having played elsewhere between each tenure, such as Paul Ince (playing for Internazionale in between) and Peter Beardsley (Vancouver Whitecaps and Newcastle United) and more recently Michael Owen (Real Madrid and Newcastle United), although Beardsley only played once for United, but went on to be a key player during his four years at Liverpool . </P> <P> In 2007, there was a bid from Liverpool to sign Gabriel Heinze from United, but United refused to allow him to join their biggest rivals due to the ongoing feud . United claimed that it was agreed Heinze would only join a foreign club if he chose to leave . Heinze went public with his request to join Liverpool which was seen as the ultimate betrayal by the Manchester United fans . The Manchester United fans who once chanted "Argentina" in honour of the player then turned their backs on him . Heinze was eventually sold to Real Madrid instead . </P> <Table> <Tr> <Th> Date </Th> <Th> Name </Th> <Th> From </Th> <Th> To </Th> <Th> Fee </Th> </Tr> <Tr> <Td> August 1912 </Td> <Td> Tom Chorlton </Td> <Td> Liverpool </Td> <Td> Manchester United </Td> <Td> </Td> </Tr> <Tr> <Td> November 1913 </Td> <Td> Jackie Sheldon </Td> <Td> Manchester United </Td> <Td> Liverpool </Td> <Td> </Td> </Tr> <Tr> <Td> September 1920 </Td> <Td> Tom Miller </Td> <Td> Liverpool </Td> <Td> Manchester United </Td> <Td> £ 2,000 </Td> </Tr> <Tr> <Td> May 1921 </Td> <Td> Fred Hopkin </Td> <Td> Manchester United </Td> <Td> Liverpool </Td> <Td> </Td> </Tr> <Tr> <Td> February 1929 </Td> <Td> Tommy Reid </Td> <Td> Liverpool </Td> <Td> Manchester United </Td> <Td> </Td> </Tr> <Tr> <Td> January 1938 </Td> <Td> Ted Savage </Td> <Td> Liverpool </Td> <Td> Manchester United </Td> <Td> </Td> </Tr> <Tr> <Td> November 1938 </Td> <Td> Allenby Chilton </Td> <Td> Liverpool </Td> <Td> Manchester United </Td> <Td> </Td> </Tr> <Tr> <Td> February 1954 </Td> <Td> Thomas McNulty </Td> <Td> Manchester United </Td> <Td> Liverpool </Td> <Td> £ 7,000 </Td> </Tr> <Tr> <Td> April 1964 </Td> <Td> Phil Chisnall </Td> <Td> Manchester United </Td> <Td> Liverpool </Td> <Td> £ 25,000 </Td> </Tr> </Table> <Tr> <Th> Date </Th> <Th> Name </Th> <Th> From </Th> <Th> To </Th> <Th> Fee </Th> </Tr>

Who has played for liverpool and manchester united