<Li> Kaylee Bryant as Sarah, a classmate of Abby and Eric </Li> <Li> Nathan Fillion as Gary West, a realtor and the Hammonds' co-worker . He is the first person Sheila kills for food . His severed head still survives and is stored in the Hammonds' basement and later storage unit . </Li> <Li> Natalie Morales as Anne Garcia, a sheriff's deputy, Dan's partner, and very religious . She becomes romantically involved with Lisa after Dan goes missing . </Li> <Li> Thomas Lennon as Principal Andrei Novak, Abby's school principal </Li>

Who plays officer garcia in santa clarita diet