<P> In the Connecticut ratifying convention, Oliver Ellsworth likewise described judicial review as a feature of the Constitution: "This Constitution defines the extent of the powers of the general government . If the general legislature should at any time overleap their limits, the judicial department is a constitutional check . If the United States go beyond their powers, if they make a law which the Constitution does not authorize, it is void; and the judicial power, the national judges, who, to secure their impartiality, are to be made independent, will declare it to be void ." </P> <P> During the ratification process, supporters and opponents of ratification published pamphlets, essays, and speeches debating various aspects of the Constitution . Publications by over a dozen authors in at least twelve of the thirteen states asserted that under the Constitution, the federal courts would have the power of judicial review . There is no record of any opponent to the Constitution who claimed that the Constitution did not involve a power of judicial review . </P> <P> After reviewing the statements made by the founders, one scholar concluded: "The evidence from the Constitutional Convention and from the state ratification conventions is overwhelming that the original public meaning of the term' judicial power' (in Article III) included the power to nullify unconstitutional laws ." </P> <P> The Federalist Papers, which were published in 1787--1788 to promote ratification of the Constitution, made several references to the power of judicial review . The most extensive discussion of judicial review was in Federalist No. 78, written by Alexander Hamilton, which clearly explained that the federal courts would have the power of judicial review . Hamilton stated that under the Constitution, the federal judiciary would have the power to declare laws unconstitutional . Hamilton asserted that this was appropriate because it would protect the people against abuse of power by Congress: </P>

Who came up with the idea of judicial review