<Tr> <Td> </Td> <Td> National Labour </Td> <Td> 8 </Td> <Td> Kilmarnock, Derby (one of two) †, Ormskirk, Leicester West, Nottingham South, Lichfield †, Leeds Central, Cardiff C </Td> </Tr> <Tr> <Td> </Td> <Td> Liberal </Td> <Td> 9 </Td> <Td> Dundee (one of two), Paisley, Birkenhead East, Bristol North, Bethnal Green South - West, Wolverhampton East, Middlesbrough West, Bradford South, Carnarvonshire </Td> </Tr> <Tr> <Td> </Td> <Td> Independent </Td> <Td> </Td> <Td> Mossley </Td> </Tr> <Tr> <Td> </Td> <Td> National </Td> <Td> </Td> <Td> Brecon and Radnor † </Td> </Tr>

How did labour win the election in 1945