<P> Suppose the batting order is: Abel, Baker, Charles, Daniel, Edward, Frank, George, Hooker, Irwin . </P> <P> Abel bats and is put out . Charles then bats out of turn . Charles makes a safe hit, reaching first base . Before any pitch is thrown to the next batter, a member of the defensive team asks the umpire to make a ruling . RULING: The proper batter after Abel was Baker, not Charles . Baker is called out for failing to bat in his turn, and Charles is removed from base and comes to bat again, because he is now the proper batter . </P> <P> For instance, on July 6, 2013, San Francisco Giants manager Bruce Bochy submitted a lineup to the umpires with Gregor Blanco leading off, Marco Scutaro batting second, Pablo Sandoval batting third and Buster Posey hitting cleanup . After Blanco got on base and Scutaro made out, Posey improperly stepped to the plate and hit an RBI double to right field, scoring Blanco from third base . However, Los Angeles Dodgers manager Don Mattingly immediately appealed to plate umpire Tony Randazzo for a ruling and after discussion amongst the umpires, Sandoval was declared out for failing to bat in his turn, Blanco was sent back to 3rd base, and Posey, who was removed from the basepaths, came to bat again because he was now the proper batter . This time around, Posey flew out to end the inning, leaving Blanco stranded . </P> <P> Abel bats and is put out . Charles then bats out of turn . Charles makes a safe hit, reaching first base . Baker then comes to bat . A strike is pitched to Baker . A member of the defensive team then asks the umpire to make a ruling regarding the improper batting order . RULING: The first pitch to Baker made Charles's turn legal . The proper batter after Charles is Daniel, not Baker . Without penalty, Daniel comes to bat (replacing Baker) and assumes that one - strike count . </P>

When is a batter out for batting out of order