<P> An early version was considered as a follow - up to "Please Please Me", and the Beatles hoped to record it on 5 March 1963, but there was only time for the other songs recorded that night: "From Me to You", "Thank You Girl", and an early version of "One After 909". </P> <P> The Rubber Soul version was recorded in one take, with overdubs, on 4 November 1965 . In the verse before the lead break after Starr sings "tell me why," Lennon can be heard saying "We already told you why!" in reference to the Beatles' "Tell Me Why" from the previous year . During this session the Beatles recorded a long (6: 36) instrumental tune called "12 - Bar Original" for lack of a better name . "12 - Bar Original" was not included on Rubber Soul, and was not commercially available until 1996 when an edited version of take 2 of this song was included on the Anthology 2 album . </P> <Ul> <Li> Ringo Starr--lead vocal, drums </Li> <Li> John Lennon--harmony vocal, rhythm guitar </Li> <Li> Paul McCartney--harmony vocal, bass guitar </Li> <Li> George Harrison--lead guitar </Li> </Ul> <Li> Ringo Starr--lead vocal, drums </Li>

Who sings what goes on by the beatles