<P> In Season Three, Piney is shown to be more active in the club . He runs the Teller - Morrow garage while his fellow members are out looking for Jax's kidnapped son Abel and Gemma is on the run from the law . When SOA members Bobby and Happy need to get medicine for family members Piney leads them his friend (Frances Fisher), who is in the pharmaceutical drug trade . They arrive at her house while she is being robbed, and they shoot it out with the robbers . Because the Sons are outgunned they end up captured but are rescued by the rest of the SOA, thanks to a call for backup by Happy . When the club needs money for their trip to find Abel they decide to sell the pharmaceuticals supplied to them by Piney's friend . </P> <P> While the club is in Belfast, Northern Ireland, Piney stays behind . He and the other SAMCRO members who stayed behind have their hands full with Jacob Hale's using Hector Salazar (former President of the Calaverez MC) to push out one of their most loyal supporters for a land development deal . When the Sons get information from Darby, Piney and Tig go to share it with Unser and ask him to investigate it, but Unser - who has been distant from the club - disregards the information . So Piney and the remaining SAMCRO members who aren't in Belfast look for Salazar but don't find him at his house . Salazar calls the club to tell them he has kidnapped Tara, and he wants the club to kill Alvarez and take $250,000 from Alvarez's home safe . The club gets Alvarez to pretend, for 24 hours, to be dead, but they can't get the money . ATF Agent June Stahl decides to help get Tara back by providing the ransom money, but the drop is compromised when some kids steal the money . The next day the rest of SAMCRO comes home, and they look for Tara . In the Season Three finale the club celebrates Abel's return, and the rest of the day the club works to tie up loose ends, which includes killing Jimmy O'Phelan . SAMCRO takes Jimmy from the Russians, but the ATF captures Jimmy at the garage, where they find out that Jax made the deal . Many SAMCRO members are arrested to face their gun charges . Piney, Opie, and Chibs are the only ones not subject to these charges and are assigned to ambush and kill Stahl and Jimmy with the help of Kozik, a Tacoma member who has been helping SAMCRO and wants to transfer to the Charming charter, and Unser . They successfully get the job done and drive away . </P> <P> In Season 4, Piney voices his disgust with Clay's decisions following the agreement to run drugs for the cartel, and he creates a rift in the club culminating in Bobby's call for a change of presidency vote . The vote is interrupted by attacks on SAMCRO and the Mayans, after which Piney goes to the cabin to clear his mind . It's also revealed that Piney is privy to the contents of some letters written by John Teller (which Tara found when she unwrapped and read the package of letters Maureen Ashby had secreted in Jax's bag and described to Piney). In these letters, JT related his concerns about the direction the club had taken, his plans to stop the gunrunning for the IRA, and his fears that he was losing Gemma and that Clay would kill him . Piney believes the latter is what eventually happened and threatens Clay that he will share those letters with Jax and the club, unless Clay pulls out of the cartel deal . Clay goes to the cabin looking for the letters and questions Piney about them, after which Clay murders Piney . Clay then stages the scene to look like a hit by the cartel . Piney is the third member of SOA's First 9 to be executed by Clay . </P>

When did piney die in sons of anarchy