<P> A lower court ruled against the government . When the government appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, the appellate court affirmed the lower court's ruling . The appellate court held that the law could not be used to intercept shipments which originated from a doctor . Judge Augustus Noble Hand wrote, in his decision: </P> <P> While it is true that the policy of Congress has been to forbid the use of contraceptives altogether if the only purpose of using them be to prevent conception in cases where it would not be injurious to the welfare of the patient or her offspring, it is going far beyond such a policy to hold that abortions, which destroy incipient life, may be allowed in proper cases, and yet that no measures may be taken to prevent conception even though a likely result should be to require the termination of pregnancy by means of an operation . It seems unreasonable to suppose that the national scheme of legislation involves such inconsistencies and requires the complete suppression of articles, the use of which in many cases is advocated by such a weight of authority in the medical world . </P>

United states v. one package of japanese pessaries