<P> Despite being a "critically acclaimed" film, according to Rotten Tomatoes, not all of its reviews were this positive . Anna Smith of Empire called it "formulaic and all - American", commenting that many scenes "appear functional rather than inspirational", and that the film focused on the racial issue "a little too heavily". Smith stated, "clunky plotting and characterisation mean it has' telemovie' written all over it ." Marc Mohan from The Oregonian stressed it can be compared to after - school specials due to its "lack of originality in plot and character ." Time Out's Jessica Winter also drew a comparation to after - school specials, saying "on the big screen...its clichés seem bigger and its characterisations broader than they would on the more forgiving telly ." Nick Schager of Slant Magazine lamented that the "clichés are too numerous to mention", while Neil Smith from BBC asserted it has "as much...fantasy as Lord of the Rings ." Jan Stuart of Newsday deemed it "virtually suspense - free, while Robert Hanks of The Independent stated it has an important message but that is a "shame it couldn't be encased in a less faked - up story". Commenting on The Times, Chris Ayres stressed that although it has good "visual flair" it "is ruined by its Oprah - style emotional manipulation ." New York Post's Kyle Smith deemed it as "uplifting but unimaginative", suggesting that "Akeelah and the Bee is so warm and well - meaning that you may find yourself wanting to like it more than you really do ." </P> <P> In spite of criticism, cast members' performances were usually well received--in particular, Palmer's portrayal of Akeelah . Ebert said, "The movie depends on her, and she deserves its trust ." Hornaday opined that "Palmer's Akeelah is that cinematic rara avis, the kid who is cute without being too cute, sympathetic without being cloying, and believable without being tiresome ." Evening Chronicle stated Palmer does it "with effortless grace" and that she "carries the film and doesn't strike a single wrong emotional note ." Fuchs felt that most of the film's strengths "have to do with Palmer's winning performance ." Ingman declared Atchison's "ensemble is wonderful, and his star, Palmer, is a fantastically assured young actress who conveys Akeelah's maelstrom of 11 - year - old feelings with no apparent effort ." Turan complimented how Fishburne and Bassett's "presence and ability give this film a welcome integrity ." Mohan stated, "Although Fishburne and Bassett can do these roles in their sleep, the kids are actually quite engaging ." Tourmakine felt there were "fine performances all around" and that Fishburne and Bassett "lend fine support in utterly believable roles". </P> <P> Chang called Dylan's father "a stiff Asian stereotype", while Mohan of The Oregonian found it contradictory for an anti-racist film to contain such depiction . Peter Bradshaw of The Guardian even claimed that the line "If you can barely beat a little black girl" (spoken by Dylan's father) signifies that Atchison "thinks it's all right to bring in racism by making the Asians the racists ." Metro Silicon Valley's Richard von Busack commented that "(s) tepping around black stereotypes, the film squishes its two left feet right in the mire of Asian stereotyping ." Beth Accomando of KPBS also criticized Dylan and his father's portrayal as "painful cliches", while Schager of Slant Magazine found it not authentic, even likening Dylan's father to Mao Zedong . </P> <P> Scholars Charise Pimentel and Cathleen Sawyer from the Texas State University published an article titled "Akeelah and the Bee: Inspirational Story of African - American Intellect and Triumph or Racist Rhetoric Served Up On Another Platter?" on the May 2011 issue of journal Multicultural Perspectives . On a critical discourse analysis, the authors argue that despite appearing to be an "inoccent enough" film, it has major approaches that make it racist . First, it implies that African - Americans needs to be rescued by others; second, depicts African - Americans community as "marked by homelessness, poverty, criminality, unemployment, and remnants of gang activity"; third, indicates that black people usually only achieve success through sports by "linking the very essence of Akeelah's phenomenal ability to spell to her rhythmic abilities"; and shows that African - Americans only can succeed outside their communities, "far from the oppressive clutches of their own ." </P>

Is the movie akeelah and the bee a true story