<P> Part 1 of 2 . A classic film lover named John (Joel Courtney) gets sucked into a 1950s B - movie called I Was A Teenage Tick Monster playing at a haunted drive - in . He soon ends up in the movie where he is pursued by the Tick Monster and the evil mad scientist Dr. Mangle (Matt Angel). </P> <P> Guest starring: Brendan Meyer as Nathan and Sarah Dugdale as Lisa </P> <Tr> <Th> 24 </Th> <Td> </Td> <Td> "Creature Feature" (Part 2) </Td> <Td> Peter DeLuise </Td> <Td> Billy Brown & Dan Angel </Td> <Td> October 8, 2011 (2011 - 10 - 08) </Td> </Tr> <Tr> <Td_colspan="6"> Part 2 of 2 . Nathan and Lisa get sucked inside the B - movie to rescue John and stop the evil mad scientist Dr. Mangle from releasing his creation on the real world . In the end, John decides to stay in the movie . Lisa and Nathan decide to leave him and go back to the real world as John wanted it this way . As the Tick Monster appears, John just quotes "fade to black" and the episode ends . </Td> </Tr>

The haunting hour the series season 4 episode 1